Carrie Underwood vs Alexis Grace
One woman has already achieved superstardom, another has yet to make use of her recent notoriety. Which one of these two women would you like to sing you a song?
Casey Carlson vs Katrina Darrell
These two 2009 American Idol contestants tried to shake things up with their looks, but were ultimately found wanting through the process. That doesn’t mean they can’t find a second life through Hottie Matchup, though.
Join the forum discussion on this post - (1) Posts
Katharine McPhee vs Kellie Pickler
American Idol always gives us the full gamut of talent: from the weakest of the weak to the cream of the crop. Katharine McPhee was a runner-up on American Idol while Pickler made it far, but not quite as far, got a boob job, and embraced stardom. Only in America.
